Practice Areas
Failure to Yield For Emergency Vehicles Tickets Lawyer in NY
japanese-culture-with-moving-car 1.png

New York City, with its bustling streets, has a stringent emphasis on road safety, especially concerning emergency vehicles. As per the "Move Over" law enshrined in NY violation code VTL 1144-a, motorists are mandated to slow down and shift to an adjacent lane when they encounter stationary emergency vehicles with activated flashing lights. This is crucial for safeguarding the lives of emergency responders, from police officers to ambulance crews.

However, not all drivers adhere to this, and those found in violation face the repercussions of a "Failure to Move Over For Emergency Vehicles" ticket. For those grappling with such tickets, James Medows emerges as a trusted traffic ticket lawyer in NYC. His adept understanding of VTL 1144-a, coupled with his vast experience in NYC's traffic laws, ensures that individuals receive comprehensive legal support when confronting the nuances of the city's traffic courts.

How do you normally get a failure to move over for emergency vehicles ticket?

A "Failure to Move Over for Emergency Vehicles" ticket is typically issued when drivers do not follow the protocols set in place to protect emergency personnel working on or near roadways. Here's how a driver might typically incur such a violation:

  • Stationary Emergency Vehicles: If you approach an emergency vehicle (like a police car, fire truck, ambulance, tow truck, or highway maintenance vehicle) that is parked on the side of the road with its lights activated, you are typically required to move over to a non-adjacent lane if it's safe and possible to do so.
  • Slow Down: If you cannot safely move to another lane due to traffic, road conditions, or the configuration of the road (like on a two-lane highway), you are generally required to slow down significantly below the speed limit while passing the emergency vehicle.
  • Ambiguous Situations: Sometimes, drivers might encounter situations where it's unclear whether they should move over, such as when there's a vehicle with flashing lights but it's not immediately identifiable as an emergency vehicle. In these situations, it's typically safer and more prudent to move over or slow down anyway.
  • Intersections: Some jurisdictions require drivers to pull over to the right side of the road and stop if an emergency vehicle is approaching with sirens and lights on, even if the emergency vehicle is coming from the opposite direction. This ensures the emergency vehicle has a clear and unobstructed path.
  • Freeways and Multi-lane Roads: On multi-lane roads or freeways, the move-over law typically requires drivers to shift lanes to give a buffer zone to emergency responders. If drivers cannot shift lanes safely, they should slow down considerably.

Failure to comply with these protocols can result in a "Failure to Move Over for Emergency Vehicles" ticket. The rationale behind these laws is to protect first responders and other emergency personnel from being struck by passing vehicles while they perform their duties on or near the roadway.


Is it worth it to challenge a “failure to move over for emergency vehicle” ticket?

Whether or not to challenge a "Failure to Move Over for Emergency Vehicles" ticket depends on several factors. Here are some considerations to help you make an informed decision:

  • Evidence: If you believe that you did move over, or if there was a valid reason why you couldn't (e.g., heavy traffic prevented a safe lane change), and you have evidence to support this, such as dashcam footage, then it might be worth challenging.
  • Severity of Penalties: These types of tickets can come with substantial fines, points on your driving record, and potential insurance rate increases. Depending on the jurisdiction, the penalties can be quite significant given the safety implications of the violation.
  • Driving Record: If you have a previous history of traffic violations, another ticket can add more points to your license, potentially leading to suspension or other repercussions. If challenging the ticket might prevent this, it could be worth the effort.
  • Legal Representation: It's beneficial to consult with a traffic attorney familiar with local traffic laws and court procedures. An attorney, such as James Medows in NYC, might offer insights into your chances of successfully contesting the ticket based on the specifics of your case and local traffic court trends.
  • Court Costs and Time: Remember to weigh the penalties of the ticket against the potential court fees, legal costs, and time spent in court.
  • Chance of Reduction: Even if you can't get the ticket dismissed, by showing up in court, there might be an opportunity to have the penalties reduced or to negotiate a plea to a lesser offense.
  • Local Trends: Some courts or judges might be more understanding, especially if you can demonstrate that you genuinely tried to move over or if you've had a clean driving record up to this point.
  • Personal Belief: If you genuinely believe you were in the right and that the ticket was unjustly issued, you might decide to challenge it on principle alone.

In conclusion, the decision to challenge a "Failure to Move Over for Emergency Vehicles" ticket should be based on a combination of personal circumstances, potential penalties, and the likelihood of a favorable outcome. Consulting with a knowledgeable traffic attorney can provide clarity and a better understanding of what to expect.