Practice Areas
Improper Passing School Bus (Non-camera) Tickets in NY
Mask group (1).png

Safety around school buses is paramount in New York City, given the city's emphasis on protecting its youngest residents. Violations related to improperly passing or overtaking a school bus are categorized under NY violation code VTL 1174. Drivers are mandated to stop for school buses when they're picking up or dropping off students, and failure to do so can result in severe penalties.

For those who find themselves faced with a non-camera school bus ticket, James Medows stands out as an experienced traffic ticket lawyer in NYC. Familiar with the nuances of VTL 1174 and dedicated to upholding the rights of motorists, Medows provides expert advice and robust representation for those navigating this specific violation. His knowledge and expertise are invaluable for drivers seeking a just outcome in New York's stringent traffic courts.

How do you normally get a school bus ticket?

Receiving a school bus ticket (non-camera) typically results from violating laws related to school bus safety. Here are common scenarios that can lead to a school bus ticket:

  • Passing a Stopped School Bus: One of the most common reasons drivers receive school bus tickets is for passing a stopped school bus that has its red lights flashing and stop-arm extended. In many jurisdictions, vehicles traveling in both directions must stop for a school bus on an undivided roadway. However, on divided highways, only vehicles traveling in the same direction as the school bus are typically required to stop.
  • Overtaking and Passing on School Property: Some jurisdictions prohibit overtaking and passing other vehicles on school property, especially during certain hours.
  • Speeding in a School Zone: Driving over the speed limit in a school zone during designated hours (usually when children are arriving at or leaving school) can result in a ticket.
  • Not Yielding to Pedestrians in School Zones: Drivers are usually required to yield the right-of-way to pedestrians in crosswalks within school zones.
  • Disobeying School Crossing Guard: Failing to follow the directions of a school crossing guard can also lead to a ticket.

These violations are taken seriously due to the heightened concern for children's safety around schools and school buses. Non-camera tickets mean that a law enforcement officer personally observed the violation and issued the ticket, as opposed to automated camera systems that might capture such violations.

Is it worth challenging a school bus (noncamera) ticket?

Challenging a school bus (non-camera) ticket can be a significant decision, as these violations are regarded gravely due to the safety risks involved. Whether or not it's worth contesting such a ticket depends on multiple factors:

  • Evidence: If you believe you didn't commit the violation and can provide evidence to support your claim (e.g., witness statements, video footage, or other proof), you may have a strong case to challenge the ticket.
  • Severity of Penalties: In many jurisdictions, school bus violations come with hefty fines, points on your driving record, potential insurance rate hikes, and even possible suspension of driving privileges. Weigh these outcomes against the costs and potential benefits of challenging the ticket.
  • Driving Record: If you've maintained a clean driving record, you might receive leniency from the court, especially if you can demonstrate that this was a one-time, inadvertent mistake. In some jurisdictions, the court might offer alternative resolutions, such as attending a defensive driving course.
  • Legal Counsel: Engaging a traffic attorney can provide a clearer understanding of your chances. An experienced lawyer, like James Medows in NYC, can guide you through the legal nuances, potential defenses, and help determine whether challenging the ticket is in your best interest.
  • Court Precedence and Practice: Some courts might be known for being more lenient on first-time offenders or for offering plea deals that reduce the charge to a lesser violation with fewer consequences.
  • Cost-Benefit Analysis: Factor in the costs of the ticket, potential long-term insurance increases, and other penalties against the expenses of challenging the ticket, including legal fees and potential lost wages from court appearances.

Given the seriousness associated with school bus violations, if you decide to challenge the ticket, it's advisable to be well-prepared. While every situation is unique, it's essential to weigh the potential risks and rewards, costs, and other implications before deciding to contest a school bus ticket.